kii said:

Apparently I have been pronouncing “broccoli” incorrectly for a while.

I say broccolie not broccolee.

I feel weird.

Huh?

I pronounce broccoli as brocco-lie with the hard I. Most people I know do. I rarely hear brocco-lee.

Mind you, the way you write “Lorelie” makes me pronounce it “Laurel-ee” as it would be in German. The German female name and navigationally difficult rock on the Rhine is written “Lorelei” and in German ends in the hard I sound.